Two new studies published in the Journal of the American Medical Association suggest that brief counseling may not be effective in counteracting drug use.
Previous research has shown brief interventions can help some problem drinkers, NPR reports.
Public health officials have been urging primary care doctors and hospital emergency rooms to ask patients about drug use, and to immediately give those with a drug problem a 10- to 15-minute counseling session, known as a brief intervention.
One of the new studies looked at more than 500 people who were determined to have a drug problem, based on a verbal screening at a primary care clinic. They were divided into three groups. The first two groups received brief counseling, while the third group received no counseling. After six months, those who had received brief counseling had not reduced drug use any more than people who received no counseling.
A second study found people who received brief counseling and a short phone call two weeks later did not reduce their drug use more than people who did not receive counseling. People with the most severe drug problems who received counseling were more likely to seek specialty care later on.
"I think it was wishful thinking that a problem as complex could be solved with a simple intervention," said Richard Saitz of Boston University, author of the first study. He said some patients who come in for a routine checkup and are told they have a serious drug problem may be overwhelmed by the information. For these patients, a brief counseling session is unlikely to help.
Dr. H. Westley Clark, Director of the Center for Substance Abuse Treatment at the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, told NPR the brief intervention model is very useful for many patients. "But as you popularize the intervention, you want to refine your approach," he noted. Clark says brief interventions may not work for severe cases of drug use. He called for better training for health care providers to help them match patients with the best treatment.
- More Prescription Drugs Withdrawn or Got Black-Box Warnings After Drug Law Passed
- More Teen Athletes Abusing Prescription Painkillers
- Treatment for Mental Health Problems Surging for Young Adults
- Prenatal Alcohol Exposure Alters Development of Brain Function
- Andrew Pucher named NCADD President CEO
- Bipartisan Bill Aims to Help Low-Level Drug Offenders Re-Enter Society
- Ban or Limit Use of E-Cigarettes, Leading Lung Organizations Urge
- New Electronic Device and Mobile App Designed to Detect ‘Date Rape’ Drugs in Drinks
- Civilian Life, Not Combat, May Drive Many Veterans to Drink
- New Painkiller That Combines Oxycodone and Naloxone Approved by FDA
- Mixing Energy Drinks With Alcohol Increases the Urge to Drink
- Amount Of Alcohol Consumed May Be Linked To All Types Of Arthritis
- College Alcohol Violations Often Draw a Slap on the Wrist
- More Evidence That Moderate Drinking May Benefit the Heart
- Opioid Painkiller Prescribing Varies Widely Among States
- How Strong Is That Drink? Calculator Helps Figure
- MGH to Screen All Patients for Substance Abuse
- Early Interventions Can Decrease Drug Use in Young Women
- Some Colleges Starting to Sell Beer at Stadiums to Increase Revenue
- Add Safety Warnings on Energy Drinks, Consumer Group Urges FDA